Spam Protection Without Clicking on Traffic Lights
Image puzzles cost real people time and shut some out entirely. Altcha gives the visitor's browser a small calculation instead, and nobody sees it.
Most of us have spent minutes of our lives picking traffic lights, buses and crossings out of a grid of blurry photos. That is the image challenge in Google’s reCAPTCHA v2, and it sits in front of a great many contact forms.
Researchers at the University of California, Irvine studied more than 3,600 people solving reCAPTCHA v2 on a live university service over 13 months. Participants found the image challenges annoying, and the authors concluded that reCAPTCHA v2 “has an immense cost and no security” (Searles, Prapty and Tsudik, 2023).
For some visitors the puzzle is worse than annoying. The W3C’s note on the subject sets out how image tests stop people who are blind or partially sighted, because a screen reader cannot describe a picture it was built to hide, and how the audio versions, played under deliberate noise, can be just as hard to use (Inaccessibility of CAPTCHA).
What our forms use instead
Altcha. When a visitor sends your form, their browser is handed a small calculation to solve. A real browser does it in a moment. A script trying to send thousands of messages has to do it thousands of times, which is the point.
The visitor has nothing to look at, click or listen to. Altcha sets no cookies and builds no profile of anyone, and on our forms it runs from our own servers, so sending your form involves no request to another company. The project is open source under the MIT licence, and describes its widget as meeting WCAG 2.2 AA (altcha.org).
A captcha on its own isn’t enough
Altcha makes each submission cost a little computing time. A bot that drives a real browser and is in no hurry will pay that cost. So Altcha is one layer of several on every form we run:
- A hidden field that people never see and bots fill in.
- A block on disposable email addresses and a limit on how often one visitor can send.
- A check on what a submission says, which drops the made-up names and random-letter messages that get past every captcha (fewer junk form submissions).
- A refusal of posts from Tor, VPNs and hosting networks, where nearly all bots run (no more form spam from Tor and server farms).
A dropped submission shows as Spam under Recent Activity on your form. In most cases the sender sees your normal thank-you page, so a bot learns nothing from being caught.
Switching it on
Open the form in your dashboard and turn on Altcha in its settings. If you use the widget or the HTML from the form’s Endpoint card, Altcha’s part is already included. The same protection is available on the booking widget.
Yesterday’s post followed a message from the Send button to your inbox.
Ready to Deploy?
Join Jamstack developers across the UK hosting their static sites with privacy and performance built in. Hosting is free for good, no credit card needed, with Plus features when you want them.
